NO NO NO NO NO NO: The Rejection Show
Show Notes
It’s December, it gets dark in the afternoon, and it’s freezing here in Ohio…what better time to dive into the cheery topic of rejection? Better yet, how about a clip show of rejection goodies? LOL, you’re welcome! This mini episode features clips from seven guests who appeared on Page Count in 2025 and offered some rejection-related insights on everything from submission strategies to the importance of separating the business from the art, writing out of spite, persistence, and beyond. Plus, Laura shares her own rejection stats from 2025. So what are you waiting for? Dust off your cover letter, log into your Submittable account, and take a listen.
The following episodes were excerpted for this rejection extravaganza:
- The Art of Editing with The Cincinnati Review
- Clicking Our Heels Three Times with Dr. Taylor Byas
- Experimental Fiction with Mary Grimm
- Page Count Live: Writing Toward Peace with Loung Ung
- Touring the Paul Laurence Dunbar House
- Librarians are Superheroes with Karen Henry Clark
- Speculative Fiction at the Columbus Book Festival
Transcript
Lisa Ampleman:
Things that I've had that have been accepted are sometimes rejected by twenty, a hundred, et cetera. That might be a sign that, you know, do you want to go back and revise? But it might just be that you haven't found the right editor yet.
Laura Maylene Walter:
Welcome to Page Count presented by the Ohio Center for the Book at Cleveland Public Library. This podcast celebrates authors, illustrators, librarians, booksellers, literary advocates, and readers in and from the state of Ohio. I’m your host, Laura Maylene Walter, the Ohio Center for the Book Fellow and author of the novel Body of Stars.
Laura Maylene Walter:
The topic for this episode is: rejection. Everyone’s favorite. If you’re a writer, you get rejected, full stop. It never ends, not even after you publish or receive awards or accolades—rejection is an unfortunate fact of the writing life. We don’t like it, but we have to face it. At the top of this episode, you heard Lisa Ampleman, Managing Editor of the Cincinnati Review, discussing her own experience with rejection—and how it sometimes comes down to connecting with the right editor at the right time. Lisa was a guest on a Page Count episode earlier this year focusing on Cincinnati Review’s submission and editing process, and she’s just one of several writers who shared insights into the wide world of rejection on this podcast. I combed through our episodes from 2025 to share additional snippets of rejection wisdom from our guests.
Laura Maylene Walter:
But before we get to that, I thought I’d share my own submission stats in 2025, to be fully transparent and to let you know I’m in this pit of rejection right along with you. I’m recording this on Friday, December 12, 2025. During the calendar year of 2025, at least to date, I have sent out a total of 53 submissions. And I’d say this number is fairly low overall; when I really get into submitting mode, I can send out many more than that, but this is what I have for 2025. As of today, here’s where those submissions stand:
Laura Maylene Walter:
Out of those 53, 41 have come back so far with the dreaded “thanks, but no thanks” response. Those rejections include six residency applications, two short fiction contests, and either 2 or 3 grant applications, depending on how you look at it, because my application for an NEA grant was technically not a rejection—the entire program was shut down, as I’m sure you know, but I’m including the NEA application in this list because, let’s face it, it would have surely been a rejection anyway had the program not been gutted. The remaining thirty rejections are all individual short story submissions spread out across five different short stories, which means each story was only rejected an average of six times. Which is nothing. <laugh> Six rejections is nothing.
Laura Maylene Walter:
I did receive two acceptances this year: one short story acceptance at a very good print magazine that I’m not naming right now because I don’t yet have a publication date, and also a Boost Fund grant from the Assembly for the Arts, which funded my recent research trip to New York and which I very much appreciate. Shoutout to Assembly for the Arts for supporting artists and writers in Cuyahoga County. I also still have ten pending submissions, though to be honest, I fully anticipate getting ten rejections in response to those submissions. But we’ll see.
Laura Maylene Walter:
It takes some stamina and guts and determination to persist through this kind of rejection, and the writers I’ve interviewed on this podcast know the score. So let’s turn to them and hear their thoughts on the topic of rejection. We'll start with Dr. Taylor Byas, who points out that most writers don’t publicly share all their rejections, as I just did, so it can be easy to think everyone else is doing better than you are because they’re only sharing their acceptances online. Comparison is the thief of joy, and social media is the tool we too often use to torture ourselves with everyone else’s good news when it feels like all we’re getting is, say, 41 rejections. Anyway. here’s Taylor:
Dr. Taylor Byas:
Social media is so necessary right to this kind of career of being a writer. You have to kind of market yourself in these ways and you have to let people know what's going on and where you'll be and what they can buy. But also in the midst of that you are just constantly bombarded with all of everyone else's accomplishments and what everyone else is winning and doing and getting. And it's so easy to get lost in comparison. What we don't see and what people don't post is all the blood, sweat and tears that it took to get there. All the rejection that it took to finally get that one acceptance and all the times they didn't get the award before they got the award. So I had to remind myself that we don't really have any idea what people's journeys look like based on what we're presented online, what's presented on social media. And also as an editor, someone who is sometimes on the other side of making those decisions, a lot of the times those rejections and not getting these things doesn't have anything to do with the quality of the work if there are so many other factors that go into these decisions and who gets these awards and what wins. And so I also think I've been fortunate to be on the other side and to have that insight and to know that, you know, the book can be a fantastic book and still maybe not win anything, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the book isn't good. Right.
Laura Maylene Walter:
When I spoke with Cleveland author Mary Grimm, she shared how times one of her stories was rejected before it was accepted (spoiler: it’s in the dozens), and why no writer should allow a few measly rejections to dictate how they feel about their own work:
Mary Grimm:
A former student of mine who had written a really, really good story. I asked him if he had sent it out and he said he had sent it out to three or four places and that nobody took it. And so he figured that there was something wrong with it and he stopped sending it out. And I said, oh my god, you know, three or four. And so I told him that I had a story that I thought was a pretty good story, it's not in this collection, called "The Freddie Mercury Sex Tapes," which was rejected 57 times before it was published. So, you know, three or four, don't make me laugh.
Laura Maylene Walter:
Three or four is nothing. I can get that many rejections for one story in one day sometimes. <laugh> One of my stories was in the Kenyon Review, and I think it was rejected 20 times before it got accepted there, that really, really, really great journal.
Mary Grimm:
Yes, it's not a matter of like logic. The last thing that I had published in the New Yorker had been rejected by five places before I sent it there. I thought it wasn't their kind of thing, which is why I didn't send it originally, but had been rejected by five places and then the New Yorker took it. So, and you kind of feel like: ha ha. <laugh>
Laura Maylene Walter:
Mary also offers some practical advice surrounding submitting—such as going after your dream publications first and not falling into the trap of thinking one journal’s rejection will in any way reflect how a different journal or editor might respond. As she says, it’s not a matter of logic.
Mary Grimm:
For a long time, I've sent everything that I write to the New Yorker first and allow them to reject it. Which is what mostly happens. And I don't simultaneously submit when I send it to the New Yorker, although I do every place else. I do have a kind of a tier, I guess informally, of places that publish work that I think is really great. One of them is the Colorado Review, which one of the stories in here is in the Colorado Review. And I've published, I think I've had three stories maybe in the Colorado Review. There are places that I'm always trying to get into and I have not yet gotten into: the Kenyon Review, the Paris Review, you know, like they're like way up there. Otherwise it's kind of scattershot really. I just keep sending them out, sending them out, sending them out.
Laura Maylene Walter:
Speaking of the numbers game, author Loung Ung offers some major inspiration regarding her debut memoir, First They Killed My Father—and a good reminder that in a flurry of no’s, just one yes is enough to change the trajectory of your writing career.
Loung Ung:
FIRST THEY KILLED MY FATHER is a story of love between a mother and a child, fathers and daughters and sons...histories and nations and culture and language and food and dreams and imaginations and Buddhism. And so it was all the stories of love that I could put into a book of a hundred thousand words that still exists, that still was there even in the midst and the darkest of times and war, even when I didn't realize the love was there. Even when I couldn't see the love and didn't believe in love, it was always there. And I sent it out to 25 publishers, received 24 rejections and it came out and it was an international bestseller.
Laura Maylene Walter:
All the greats have been rejected — including Paul Laurence Dunbar, the first Black American poet who gained national recognition for his work. When I visited the Paul Laurence Dunbar House in Dayton this year, I shared part of a rejection letter that Dunbar received and then asked Site Manager Ryan Qualls what role rejection played in Dunbar’s life. Take a listen.
Laura Maylene Walter:
I did want to share with everyone a rejection he received from the Century Magazine in 1895. So this would have been before his rise to fame: "Dear Mr. Dunbar, there are some very nice things about these poems, which you have sent us. And I am sorry that none of them takes us by the throat, so to speak. We can only print a small part of the literary output of any one poet..." and it goes on. But I also want to point out that the editor spells his name wrong, spells Laurence with a W instead of a U. But I think writers can really recognize that language in that rejection. We get similar things to this day. And it was the Century Magazine, I learned just by watching your short video earlier, that later in his career, a few years later when he was famous, the Century Magazine threw him a reception. And I think he was really involved with them. But do you have anything you can share about maybe his relationship to rejection, either before or after his fame? We already talked about the dialect issue.
Ryan Qualls:
I think it is a serious hurdle in his career and in his life and as a professional writer is the rejection, which is coming from all angles. And I think another poet and author to sort of think of as a comparison is Edgar Alan Poe, he's the first American poet to attempt to live on the royalties from his writing. And he dies near penniless, distraught over family losses and his health weakened by substance abuse. And so in some similar ways, Paul's trying to do that same thing. And from the very beginning, he gets out of high school and he's got a high school diploma and many individuals do not. He goes to local businesses and tries to get a job. And he wants to get a job as a clerk. And they say, "Well, to go to loading docks," 'cause of the color of his skin. He's directed towards that work. That's something that he continually dealt with in a lot of different areas in his life. When it came to how he published, what he was allowed to do, his first Broadway play was called CLORINDY, or THE ORIGIN OF THE CAKEWALK. It got together an all-Black cast, Black production. They didn't actually have permission to run through the show. They went to Broadway and they didn't tell their performers and they just started doing it. And my understanding is that when it was seen, it was like, "Oh, this is good." So they allowed them to bring the show up to the rooftop, but with the heat and the street and the noises, you lost some of the pieces Dunbar had created and so, it was shortened, but they showed they could do it. They showed that they could create this, and that it was not only successful, but with his second Broadway play, it was actually printed in sheet music and sold around the country. So that adds to that whole piece.
Laura Maylene Walter:
Yeah. I think that's a good lesson for anyone really, is that if you want to create something, just do it. Just get started. And don't wait for permission, necessarily. Yeah.
Laura Maylene Walter:
While you don’t need to get permission before you write or submit, professionalism goes a long way. Let’s hear from Lisa Ampleman again, who encourages writers to maintain good submission etiquette and to keep the business and creative parts of the writing life separate.
Lisa Ampleman:
I think it's important to treat the business of poetry as a business, and try and keep it emotionally separate from your identity as a writer and what it means for you as a writer. I had a poetry professor, Eric Pankey, who suggested doing the business of poetry, the submissions, et cetera, at a separate time, separate day than your creative work. Physical space can be really important for me psychologically. So, I don't sit in my comfy green chair to send poems out on Submittable. I would also say try and learn the etiquette if you're especially brand new to submitting. Because we use Submission Manager, we have had so many people who we've accepted who say, "Oh no, it's already been accepted elsewhere," and they forgot to withdraw it. You know, in some cases I think that's because people get used to Submittable. It's so easy, it's well-designed in that way. You can do a couple clicks and withdraw from a couple magazines, but to keep track of other places, because there are more, there are other magazines who use Submission Manager. I know magazines are using Duosuma or Moksha. And it helps us out to know to take that off the table.
Laura Maylene Walter:
What it really comes down to for writers is never giving up; I really believe that. Karen Henry Clark, author of the picture book LIBRARY GIRL, talks about facing rejection early in her career and the advice she received that boils down to this: there’s no crying in rejection. (But let me interject here just to say that yes, there totally is sometimes crying in rejection, and some rejections hit harder than others, and it’s okay to feel hurt or disappointed — but ultimately, if you're going to succeed, you’re going to have to absorb that rejection without letting it crush you.) Here’s Karen with more:
Karen Henry Clark:
And so I'd send manuscripts off, and nobody bought anything, but they were really encouraging and said, "I'm so sorry to say, this isn't quite what we're looking for, but keep doing this." You have to find little nuggets of encouragement, or you'll give up. And I foolishly thought, "Well, this is it. I'm going to get it!" And so I'd call Florence and say, "I got another rejection." And I'd be sort of tearful, and she'd say, "Well, Karen, I have shoe boxes filled with rejection letters and I keep them under my bed." Well, I don't know that I'd want to sleep on top of the rejection letters, but that was her system. And she said, "If you're going to cry every time you're rejected, you'll have to find something else to do."
Laura Maylene Walter:
At the end of the day, I can’t convince you to keep going. I don’t think anyone can do that. Every writer has to find their own internal drive to continue writing and submitting despite all the rejection. Edward Underhill, author of THE IN-BETWEEN BOOKSTORE, offers this advice: when all else fails, write out of spite.
Edward Underhill:
Write out of spite <laugh.> I mean, no, but I actually heard another author say that, and it did feel like it cracked something open for me, because there is so much rejection at every single stage, and I'm really good at rejecting myself, also. So, I will second-guess an idea for a long time. I'm working on a book now that my agent is supposed to have in a month, and I have rewritten the first chapter like, 500 times. I honestly think that the further you get, the more second-guessing, because you have more and more voices in your head. You're worrying about reader expectations for your next thing, or you're worrying about editor expectations, or agent expectations, or whatever, and it's really, really easy for me to get sort of down about all of that. Luckily, I can get down and feel like shit about it for a day or two, and then I'm just like, "You told me I couldn't do it. I'll do it anyway," including to myself sometimes. So, I really feel like that has kept me going because you can learn the craft stuff, you can figure all of that out, you can find a team of people to help you with all of that, but you have to have a reason, internally, to keep going.
Laura Maylene Walter:
I'd like to thank all the writers who spoke with me on Page Count this past year, to share their thoughts on not only rejection but so much more. In the show notes, I’ll link each of the specific episodes featuring the authors excerpted here. The last thing I’ll leave you with is a reminder that community can help you endure the rejection. Yes, we usually write alone, and submit alone, and open those rejection emails alone, but it doesn’t have to be an isolating or shameful experience. All the writers around you are being rejected, too, I promise. So maybe connect with some fellow writers to get together for writing or submission sessions. Better yet, organize a rejection contest, where the person who receives the most rejections in a set period of time wins a prize. I have done this, and it’s pretty fantastic because every rejection you receive is actually sort of a win, so that's fun. Another tip: if you happen to be in the company of other writers when you get a rejection email pops up on your phone, feel free to share your bad news with them right there on the spot. I did this recently; I was at a party full of writers when I got a rejection and I gleefully shouted it out and everyone cheered for me. It was nice. Highly recommend.
Laura Maylene Walter:
Well, 2025 is coming to a close, but we have a whole new year ahead of us full of writing, and submissions, and yes, rejections, but who knows — maybe an acceptance or two, as well. Because the thing is, you’ll never get those acceptances unless you open yourself up to rejection. So everyone, thank you for listening to Page Count this year, and good luck out there in the rejection trenches. I'll be right there with you.
Laura Maylene Walter:
Page Count is presented by the Ohio Center for the Book at Cleveland Public Library. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and leave a review for Page Count wherever you get your podcasts. Learn more online, or find the edited transcript for this episode at cpl.org/podcast/page-count/. Follow us on Instagram at Ohio Center for the Book, or find us on Facebook. If you'd like to get in touch, email ohiocenterforthebook@cpl.org, and put "podcast" in the subject line. Thanks for listening, and we'll be back in two weeks for another chapter of Page Count.
If you enjoy Page Count, please subscribe and spread the word. Get in touch by emailing us (put “podcast” in the subject line) or find us on Instagram, Twitter or Facebook. Learn more about Cleveland Public Library.