Cleveland’s 1906 Address Change

In 1906, Cleveland underwent a tremendous shift in city structure that still affects Cleveland's local history.

Cleveland’s 1906 Address Change

In 1906, Cleveland underwent a tremendous shift in city structure that still affects Cleveland’s local history. The 1906 address change standardized the naming and numbering system for Cleveland streets, adding structure to the hodgepodge of non-standard systems that dominated the 19th century.  

Although the address change was implemented in 1906, it took years to get the ordinance proposed, ratified, and revised, but citizens were talking about the need for a new system years before it was brought before government agencies. 

The problems with Cleveland’s original address system, or the lack of a system, were myriad. Street numbers were inconsistent to the point of being absurd; odd and even numbers were on the same side of the street, and major streets would use multiple different numbering systems. Until 1906, all streets were named, and there were no numbered streets to distinguish the distance from downtown/Public Square, the city’s operational center line. 

The inconsistency was documented in a 1900 Plain Dealer article, “Citizens Fume Over Numbers.” The article quoted an employee for the Cleveland Directory Company, who explained,  

“There are some of the smaller streets which have never been officially numbered. The streets have been opened, and the residents and house owners have taken the numbers which best suited their minds, and they have allowed it to go at that.”1 

Another Plain Dealer article compared Cleveland’s streets to Guangzhou, China, known to Westerners as “Canton”, China. The article quoted Chamber of Commerce Secretary F.A. Scott,  

“There is no system in effect in Cleveland in either the naming of the streets or the numbering of the buildings and after more than two years of study of the situation in Cleveland, as compared with other large cities, I incline to the belief that there is but one city in the world that can equal us in confusion and that is Canton, China.”2  

The article went on to explain that other major cities like Philadelphia, Chicago, Kansas City, and Indianapolis had encountered the same problem and adopted a universal address system, like the one proposed in Cleveland.  

The expansion and the development of the city was gradual, with Cleveland consistently annexing sections of the county throughout the 19th and 20th centuries.3 As described in the November 2, 1900, Plain Dealer article, citizens could open their own streets, name it after themselves, the landowners, or another descriptive element of the neighborhood, without a consistent numbering or naming structure.  

For example, the 1858 Map of Cuyahoga County shows the names of lot owners as “H.H. Dodge” and “Geo[rge] C. Dodge” and “Dodge Street” (present-day East 17th St.) stretched between Euclid Ave. And Superior Ave. to match the Dodge owner’s lots.4 

1858 Map of Cuyahoga County (cropped)

Other examples can be seen between 1858 and the 1874 Atlas of Cuyahoga County Ohio from Actual Surveys by and Under the Direction of D.J. Lake. Although F.B. Payne was identified as a lot owner in the 1858 map (to the immediate east of Perry St.), he didn’t have a street name. By 1874, Payne Ave. ran between Euclid Ave. and Superior Ave. and numerous Payne names, including H.B. Payne and the Payne Brothers, own property on either side of the street.5 

1874 Atlas of Cuyahoga County from Actual Surveys by and Under the Supervision of J.D. Lake, Part 19.
1874 Atlas of Cuyahoga County from Actual Surveys by and Under the Supervision of J.D. Lake, Part 19 (cropped)

By the time the 1906 address change took effect, Cleveland had recently annexed Glenville, the village of South Brooklyn, and West Cleveland village. The city expanded throughout the 20th century. Some late additions included the annexation of West Park in 1923, Miles Heights Village in 1932, and a section of Brook Park, the land occupied by the Cleveland Hopkins Airport, in 1946. 6 

Territorial Growth of the City of Cleveland, 19603

In 1902, the Chamber of Commerce advocated for a renumbering system in the city. A Plain Dealer article written at the time identified the Chamber’s concerns with the existing address system as general confusion and delivery delays.7  

Although the Chamber of Commerce had just begun the (unbeknownst to them) years-long process of initiating the city address change, the proposal experienced its first delay in early 1903. The Chamber decided to delay the renumbering proposal until the Spring 1903 election of a new City Council.8

By June 1903, the chairman of the municipal committee of the Chamber of Commerce, E.H. Baker, conferred with the President of the Board of Public Service, W.J. Springborn, to assess the renumbering plan designed by City Engineer, William J. Carter. With a few modifications, including combining streets and renaming similar-sounding streets, the plan was found to be satisfactory.9

The major address shift in Cleveland was slowly moving forward, but public sentiment was not a guarantee. In a “Letters from the People” published in late 1903 in the Plain Dealer, Postmaster C.C. Dewstoe expressed misgivings about renaming the north-south streets to numbers. He said that numbers were harder to read and espoused what would be a common opinion in the following years; the sentimental attachment to street names that were scheduled to be changed. At the end of his letter, Dewstoe was a bit of a fortune teller when he wrote,  

“There is one other aspect of the case…a sweeping change of this kind might antagonize so large a number of people, either through sentiment or for business reasons, that it will provoke a revolutionary loyalty, resulting in the election of a new city council adverse to this, which would lead to the revocation of the entire scheme and thus destroy the really valuable features of the plan.”10 

He didn’t know it, but the Postmaster had insight that would rear its head in Cleveland’s renaming and renumbering plan. 

The Chamber of Commerce approved the renumbering plan in a special meeting on December 22, 1903. The Chamber recommended the plan and its passage to the City Council. The Plain Dealer provided more information about the plan in an article published in the next edition: 

“The names of streets running in an easterly and westerly direction are to remain unchanged. The streets running in a northerly and southerly direction are to be numbered. The line running through the Public square [sic] from north to south forms, roughly, a line of demarcation east and west of which the north and south streets will be numbered in the order of their recession toward the city limits…This system of numbering north and south streets will greatly simplify the street nomenclature, for the reason that these constitute the great majority of Cleveland streets. They are also the least known streets.”11 

In November 1904, after almost 2 years of planning, the street naming and numbering ordinance was introduced to Cleveland City Council. The Plain Dealer reported that city conformity to the system was the goal and listed dozens of north-south streets which would be changed to numbered streets. A brief excerpt of the list reads: 

“Alabama street becomes Twenty-sixth street N.E.; Amesbury avenue, Ninety-fourth street, N.E.; Ami court becomes One Hundred and First street, N.W.; Anndale street, One Hundred and Eighteenth street, N.E.; Ansel avenue from St. Clair to Lake streets, Eighty-second street, N.E., and for the balance of its distance, Ansel avenue, S.E…“12 

However, the City Council found so many changes had to be made to the original ordinance, that in January 1905, they passed a new measure to meet the city’s needs. After a multi-year process, the address change was scheduled to take effect December 1, 1905, but that would also eventually be delayed.13 

In April 1905, the Plain Dealer published the full extent of Ordinance 47575-A, which described thoroughfares and listed a series of streets whose names would be changed.14 With the ordinance passed, Cleveland was finally trudging its way toward updating 250,000 house numbers and 10,000 street signs.15  

Although the city was moving forward, from a government standpoint, citizens still expressed dismay and concern over the planned system. Neighbors on the south side of the city lamented the loss of their sentimental street names, including Jennings Ave (West 14th St.) and Pearl St. (West 25th St.).16  

Dewstoe, the Postmaster, also announced his concerns again in an October 1905 letter to Vice Mayor, C.W. Lapp. The Postmaster pointed out the burden to learn a new system during the holiday season and implored the council to move back the implementation date until May 1906. The holiday season would be in full swing by December, however, the Council originally chose the date to allow enough time to update the Cleveland City Directory. In response to Postmaster Dewstoe, and what the City Council called “common consent,” the implementation of the address change was again moved back, but just to January 1,1906.17 After the pushback, the City Council decided to implement the ordinance in the new year, which was estimated to take three to seven months.18 

If January presented logistical issues, February 1906 had political ones. Although the renumbering process had already begun, Cleveland Councilman Joseph Krause threatened to introduce an ordinance that would repeal the renaming and renumbering ordinance, thus restoring the old street names. Acting Mayor Charles W. Lapp, who was serving in Tom L. Johnson’s stead, stated that he was adamantly opposed to any attempt to change the approved system.  

January 1, 1906, finally arrived, and after a long journey and many criticisms, the city began the process of changing the street name and number signs. Although the ordinance had overcome pushback, delays, and revisions, the issues in January 1906 came down to brass tacks. Literally, there was a shipping delay from Philadelphia, so the brass tacks used to attach the house numbers could not be adhered to.19 That same month, workers ran out of small numbers, specifically twos and threes, to renumber the streets.20 Despite these functional mishaps, the renaming process began in earnest in early 1906. 

An updated 1906 map of Cleveland reflecting the January 1, 1906 implementation of the address change.
Title card for The Forman-Basset-Hatch Company Map of Cleveland and Vicinity, 1906.
Detail view of either side of the Cuyahoga River on the Map of Cleveland and Vicinity, 1906

Although the pushback continued from citizens and politicians alike, people involved with the renaming and renumbering project modified some aspects to make it simpler. In the same City Council meeting where Krause threatened the entire project, Engineer Carter amended the ordinance to specify, 

“The measure provides that all short, disconnected thorofares [sic] that are not dead ends shall be called avenues and streets instead of courts and places…That all numbered streets and places shall be officially designated by only using a prefix E or W.”  

Originally, the new street names were supposed to be specified with a suffix, “NE, SE, NW, SW”, but Carter’s amendment streamlined the naming process. Carter’s amendment was prescient, considering Cleveland has kept the same standard since 1906.21 

As 1906 continued, opposition to the street plan remained. In March 1906, a Plain Dealer article detailed the sentiments of business owners in the city. R.K. Pelton, of Barstow & Pelton, had begun to circulate a petition in the merchant community to repeal the plan. Numerous businessmen vocalized their opposition to repeal the plan including the Chamber of Congress President Springborn, 

“I believe the system is meritorious, it is much better, to say the least, than the old hodge-podge we operated under previously.”22 

The business owner’s sentiment boiled down to “give the new plan a chance.” The Chamber of Commerce members would continue to voice their support for the plan by adopting a unanimous resolution, which was published in a March 9, 1906, City Council Bulletin, 

“Whereas, the ordinance providing for renumbering the streets and houses has been in effect only two months and by reason of unavoidable delays the new house numbers are not yet all in place…the [Cleveland Chamber of Commerce] board take this opportunity of reminding our citizens that the new system of numbering was unanimously adopted after more than two years of careful consideration and after it had received approval of the Retail Merchants Board, the Retail Grocers’ Association, the Builders’ Exchange, the Fire Underwriters’ Exchange, the Cleveland Chamber of Commerce, as well as the telegraph companies, the street railway companies, the express companies, the gas company, and other 
private companies directly interested…” 

In the same City Council bulletin, C.H. Patton from the Cleveland Inspection Bureau admitted that insurance companies had initially opposed the restructured street plan because of the cost to update and reprint fire insurance atlases. However, Patton stated that if the plan were repealed, as people had requested, the cost to print atlases would be several thousand dollars, and they would be woefully incomplete.  

1896 Revised 1910 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps of Cleveland, Volume 1 Title Page
1896 Revised 1910 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps of Cleveland, Volume 1 Sheet 32

Elsewhere in the bulletin, doctors and “Ladies of the East End” also requested that the new street names and numbers be repealed.23 

As the renumbering and renaming project progressed, and the calls for repeal continued, another adversary revealed himself. In June 1906, Councilman A.J. Hirstius proposed Ordinance No. 4891, a surprise repeal of Ordinance 47575-A and its revisions.24 Ordinance 47575-A had faced earlier attempts to overturn the street naming, but previous efforts had quickly fizzled out due to lack of support. Hirstius’ ordinance was similarly received. But it was submitted to the Council on June 10, 1906. The proposal appeared to die without a public hearing.25 

After years of debate, amendments, attempted appeals, and city-wide discourse, the renumbering and renaming plan for Cleveland was completed. By the time a March 1907 advertisement for water bills was published, the controversial name change became innocuous, “When asking for bills, new street name and number must be given.”26 

More than 100 years after the monumental change, Cleveland has maintained its address system and influenced the rest of Cuyahoga County’s street system. Cleveland made a tremendous bet on the city’s future at the beginning of the 20th century, which persisted throughout the Forest City’s storied history. 

The 1906 address change is a footnote in Cleveland history, but it affects researchers to this day. Anyone researching property before the 1906 address change will have to translate the post-1906 address to the pre-1906 address. The pre and post1906 resources can also answer questions about property ownership, genealogy, urban design, and local Cleveland history.  

Written by Lisa Sanchez, Map Collection Librarian

1906 Address Change Resources at the Library 

Old & New Street Numbers 

The Old & New Street Numbers index provides a handy key to pre-1906 and post-1906 street names and numbers. The reference book is available in the Center for Local and Global History, Map Collection, and Photograph Collection. The resource can also be viewed online on the Library’s Digital Gallery: Old & New Street Numbers. 

Cleveland City Directories 

A city directory is an alphabetic listing of residents, businesses, public buildings, schools, and societies. Entries usually include names, occupations, and other information. The 1906 – 1907 Directory lists addresses prior to change in parentheses. There are numerous editions of the City Directories available on the Library’s Digital Gallery: Cleveland City Directories. The physical copies of the City Directories are available in the Center for Local and Global History.

Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps 

The Sanborn Fire Insurance maps were produced throughout the 19th and 20th centuries to evaluate the insurance liability of structures in urbanized areas. This 1896 volume, corrected in 1910, shows a significant change in Cleveland over 14 years. The maps were physically updated with pasted-over corrections. Updates could include building changes, address adjustments, and updated water resources. In 1906, Cleveland converted to a universal address system, including the land annexed to the city over the previous decades. This change required many adjustments, including renaming the streets and shifting the address numbering system. The 1896 Revised 1910 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map is available on the Library’s Digital Gallery, with many other editions of the plat atlases: 1896 Rev. 1910 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map of Cleveland. The physical copies of the Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps of Cleveland are available in the Map Collection.

Citations 

  1. Citizens Fume Over Numbers. (1900, November 2). Plain Dealer p. 10.  
  1. Cleveland in Canton’s Class. (1904, December 22). Plain Dealer p 5.
  1. Rose, G.W. (1990). Cleveland: The making of a city. Kent State University Press.
  1. Hopkins, G. M. Jr. (1858). Map of Cuyahoga County, Ohio [Map]. S.H. Matthews.  
  1. Lake, D.J. (1874). Atlas of Cuyahoga County Ohio from Actual Surveys by and Under the Direction of D.J. Lake. Titus, Simmons & Titus
  1. City of Cleveland, City Plan Commission. (1960). Territorial Growth of the City of Cleveland [Map].   
  1. New Numbers on City Houses. (1902, November 6). Plain Dealer p. 12.
  1. Will Wait for New Council. (1903, March 5). Plain Dealer p. 10.
  1. Want Street Names Changed. (1903, June 20). Plain Dealer p. 10. 
  2. Letters from the People: Postmaster Dewstoe Makes Suggestion. (1903, December 20). Plain Dealer p. 3
  3. Approved by the Chamber. (1903, December 23). Plain Dealer p. 1 & p. 5.
  4. For Decision of the Council. (1904, November 29). Plain Dealer p. 7.
  5. Substitute Adopted. (1905, January 17). Plain Dealer p. 6.
  6. Legal Notices: Ordinance No. 47575-A. (1905, April 18). Plain Dealer p. 11.
  7. Big Variety of Bids. (1905, May 12). Plain Dealer p. 12.
  8. Don’t Want to Lose Old Names. (1905, May 23). Plain Dealer p. 12.
  9. File No. 2459. (1905, October 2). Council Proceedings p. 461. Provided by the Cleveland City Council Archives.
  10. Respite is Given for Old Streets. (1905, October 21). Plain Dealer p. 14
  11. Brass Tacks Cause Delay. (1906, January 10). Plain Dealer p. 4.
  12. Twos and Threes Scarce. (1906, January 28). Plain Dealer p. 9.
  13. Street Naming is Simplified. (1906, February 27). Plain Dealer p. 4.
  14. To Give New Plan Fair Trial. (1906, March 8). Plain Dealer p. 10.
  15. File No. 3432. (1906, March 9). Council Proceedings p. 92. Provided by the Cleveland City Council Archives.
  16. Ord. No. 4891. (1906, June 11). Council Proceedings p. 323. Provided by the Cleveland City Council Archives.
  17. Wants Public Meeting. (1906, June 20). Plain Dealer p. 3.
  18. Water Bills. (1907, March 31). Plain Dealer p. 4.